Somebody once asked me if I believed in evolution or creation. My response was a chuckle.
From the time I was little, I was fascinated with the world around me: how people respond to hardship, the way in which some use religion to justify their behavior, and--perhaps most importantly--who was right.
Coming from a largely secular family, these questions were ones that I kept to myself in fear of chauvinistic responses; because I spent much of my childhood with my grandpa, my perspective of the world was shaped at a susceptible age to emanate that of a liberal. Since I was little, I vehemently questioned the mindset of conservatives and eventually became irascible when someone would disagree with my view on politics. Yes, I abandoned Hot Wheels at the young age of 11 to deliberate something from which some adults even abstain.
Growing up, I tried to take the world around me from an objective position. My family returned to the Catholic church and--almost immediately--I began to appreciate the world from a different angle. Unbelieveably, I still remained pro-choice--yes, going to church did augment my belief that the views of liberals were "right"--and believed in welfare, restrictions on guns, and the separation of church and state.
While some conservatives believed that America should be run on Christian values, I questioned the fact that they simulatenously resented Middle Eastern countries for adopting a theocracy: basing their government on the morals of the Islamic religion. I couldn't fathom the hypocrisy.
It was sickening to me that conservatives refuted the morality of welfare and even considered it profuse. I've heard it many times, but I will grudgingly repeat it: "Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime." That's very cute, but extremely idealistic. While social mobility is promised in America, people like us don't understand that some poor folks absolutely cannot conquer their situation.
Is that their fault? No. The conditions under which some are oppressed simply do not allow for mobility on the socioeconomic ladder. Yet, some religious conservatives exhort that they deserve no help. How Christian.
Then, there's the old adage: "Guns don't kill people, people kill people."
Don't people kill people with guns, though?
I completely abandoned my aforementioned Catholic perspective, however, when a Catholic friend ridiculed my refutaiton of creationism. When I was asked whether I believe in evolution or creation, I said neither.
That was my response not only to this friend, but to the world. A world that exposes us to the undeniable facts of science and juxtaposes them every Sunday with the promise of salvation and faith with the simple acceptance of creation. My response was the rebellion to conform to these two contrasting concepts--ideas.
I'm a liberal who believes in a God that embraces the good in people and the salvation of the world beyond life. My god is not concerned with the mundane convictions of humans that digress the true accomplishment of religion: to be able to love one another and yourself and achieve peace.
Alec, as I have said before, your posts on the blog never cease to defy the depths of my brain. You are a very gifted writer.
ReplyDeleteIn saying that, I can appreciate the view you take of the world, as well. I understand your fascination with the world and people. And I can certainly agree with the loving one another and yourself and achieving peace; if only it were that easy. Just as it is not easy for the poverty-stricken to climb up (or simply move on) the socioeconomic ladder, so it is not easy to simply love your enemies and receive true peace. It would be nice, correct? Then again, a lot of things in the world we live would be nice, and are as of yet unavailable to us as human beings.
The adage you stated is what you said: cute and quixotic. However, as human beings, it is a nearly tangible idea, and many cling to it. I do agree that it is just not that simple. In a perfect world, there would not be a poor soul around. But there are many things that would be different if we lived in a perfect world.
"Never cease to defy the depths of my brain"??? I'm so glad I took this class, you guys always push me to stive to be better when I see your writings...
DeleteAs someone important to me once said, "Poverty is not a lack of money, but the proof of misguided money." --Robb Thompson
In all honesty, poverty many times is what I call a "generational curse," in which what he did, she did and what thier parents did, they did, and just a cycle of never-ending repetitional errors. But the people who step out and stop, and do something extraordinary, get out of that. I've heard so many testimonies (as they are not "stories") of people who, especially at young ages, got up and did something that they thought was 'hard,' or 'unachievable.' But when the finish line came, they were super successes in what they did and loved. REAL people doing very REAL things to make a difference in their own lives and get out of their generational curses and start anew.
A great book for you sarah I think would be "Do Hard Things," an incredible book that I read and loved written by successful teens, for teens who are doing nothing, and you know what the 'trick' is?--DO SOMETHING.
I agree with Sara, that was mind blowing, I loved it. xD
Deletei agree with sara and abadee(: you're writing is jus so amazing. I hope that one day i could be half the writer you are.
DeleteAlec, I'm going to start by saying that you never cease to astound me. You, my friend, with infinite vocabulary and a beautiful way of placing it all, were born to be a poet. I don't care what else you do with your life, but if you do not persue poetry, or at the very least, some form of writing, it will be a great loss on the world.
ReplyDeleteDespite my undaunting belief that there is no higher being, I agree with everything else you have stated here.
I feel as if you lived the life opposite of mine. I come from a strict-catholic-family-turned-lazy, and I thought of not a thing up until a year and a half ago, if we're going to ballpark it.
But, based on the opinions within this mind, I feel as if we have arrived at similar conclusions up until this point in our lives.
"Give a man a fish, and you will feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish, and you will feed him for a lifetime."
I never thought much of this quote until you brought it up. One hundred years ago, maybe more, this quote would have rang true. But now....Now, success and even a full stomach ride completely on what your family's wealth is and the decisions you make when you are young and fresh to the world. I also believe that the economic problems going on all over are directly related to overpopulation and a shortcoming of demand. Or, for simple's sake: Supply = High, Demand = Low. We have enough supply, and not enough demand based on the supply. Therefore, people have no money coming in because there is no where to work, because there is not much work to do, because people don't want as much stuff as there are people, and it loops back to the supply and demand idea.
How, in the name of everything, did I start with the economic situation?
Back to the point, I suppose....
The quote about the fish, in no way, relates to getting by in this world anymore.
Going into an anarchist's rant here, I believe that America, and probably the general populous of the world's countries, are hypocritical. Everything has become a tournament of fame and popularity; everyone scrabbles over everyone else to get the golden power, like a pile of repungant rats. We will do absolutely anything and everything for power. Or, anyway, the majority of us will.
Which brings me to my next point: "Guns don't kill people, people kill people."
While guns were designed, specifically, to kill, they are not what pulls the trigger. People pull the trigger, make the decision to try and hurt something else. Is it different from the bows and arrows the Indians used to hunt and fight with other tribes? Is it different from the knives humans design to be aerodynamic and bloodthirsty? Is it different from something as simple as a rope, a light bulb, a pencil? Anything can be used to kill. Anything and everything. It all depends on who is holding it within their grasp.
That being said, I agree with your statement that guns should be illegal, based purely on the fact that people simply do not know how to control themselves with anything, especially something that is of the more troubling variety.
Seeing my little sister run around our family room in her walker, laughing at the mundane and idiotic and innocent, with her trusting eyes and round face -- I dread the day when I will have to watch the realization of the world fall down upon her and crush this little girl I see now.
I do not want to give birth myself for many reasons; one, being it strains the human body to a terrible extent, and the second because I couldn't bear to bring myself to create a new person in a world so damaged, aflame, and so full of harrowing depression that continues to grow every second that it progresses in its time.
To end, Alec, I believe we should talk much more often, because your views on everything intimidate, astound, challenge, and agree with my own in ways that I cannot fit into the end of a post. I'll see you in Creative Writing on Thursday, and maybe speak sooner.
I read this on my phone, so I didnt realize how long this comment really was until I came to the site on my computer....
DeleteAnyway, the world is an ugly thing, and I can see your point and views on birth, however I myself was completely unaware of "the world" until highschool, and in all honest, I didnt know any swear word except for crap and ass (as the legitimate term), until I reached 6th grade and ASKED someone what the f-word was. Parenting plays a big part of your life in this world, and whether they prepare you, or sit back is soley up to them. My parents however took initiative and taught me and disciplined me so that I would know what was right and ethical, and what was wrong and distrustful. They were giving me my tools for my life, and now whether or not I apply them is not up to them anymore, but up to me.
...actually it was middle school... sorry.
DeleteI know you say that this world is too harsh and ruins the innocent minds of children... but I think if you were a mom, you'd be great and not let the world corrupt him/her.
DeleteWell let me just say this first: my vocab is poopy. Yes, I used the word poopy. Why? Because I can barely understand half of the big words you say at times. Why else? Because that's how I feel when I read cotton, Sarah, or your posts. And I just read them all in order. 0_0 But onto what you said--
ReplyDeleteIt's very interesting, as it always is, to read what you have to say Alec, and at times I can't seem to fathom what's going on in your head or WHY you would not what to read what you write. It's incredible.
As you said about creation and evolution, I believe in creation and deterioration. Let me explain. I believe that God created the world when he said "Be," just like the bible, and the Torah say, but after the fall of man, sin corrupted the world and things started to deteriorate, and are still deteriorating now. Many have done extensive research on what the earth would have been like "in the beginning," and it's amazing what they found. I won't get into details because it's a very long topic, by basically the earth's atmosphere was much different and in turn had a very peculiar and yet awe inspiring effects. They made a sort of "Bio-sphere" and had these environmental ideas put in place, and they found that after not even a month, snakes venom was not poisonous, a type of bug doubled in volume in a week, and even ostriches could fly. So when asked specifically, I answer creation, but really I also believe in "evolution", or rather the de-evolution or deterioration of the earth.
On the topic of values of the country, whether religious or not, Christian values are ethical. Many old movies show what seems to be a fantasy land that could never have happened, where men held open doors, where EVERYONE took off hats at the anthem, where a man would give up his seat for a woman, where kids referred to elders as sir and ma'am and would get smacked if they didn't, where the elderly were respected, where the very first thing you said at school was the pledge, and you said it no matter what, when people actually looked up to those in authority…Those aren't fantasy. Those values and morales existed and people have left them behind, when they were here not even too long ago. It's funny actually, how much the bible talks about respect, of which many don't give others anymore. Me and sarah every other day hold open the cafeteria door for people to walk in, and only a select few say thank you. It's sad. And pathetic. Why does it seem that respect and excellence in what you do has become a lost cause? My beliefs and church focus on that more than almost any place in the world. People from around the globe come and tell us these things, that we are known for our emphasis on excellence and generosity. But why does it have to be such a shock? Growing up with these values, I hadn't realized how corrupt the world was until I "got out there," and you know what? The world is ugly. Focusing only on power and money is an ugly thing.
(too many characters, continued on next comment...sorry for talking too much)
(continuation of previous comment)
ReplyDeleteThat's another thing that our values focus on--submission. It sounds like a bad thing to some, but how so? Have you ever noticed that someone who is full of self-pride and arrogance is (for lack of a better term) unattractive? It's the people who are willing to learn and open that are beautiful. The stuarts over what has been given to them. I could go on and on about this, but for the sake of your time and space, I won't.
I find both phrases very interesting. Not necessarily in the aspect that they are to be taken literally, but that they are metaphorical. I heard a funny story once, about a man who saw a homeless person on the side of a highway asking for money. the man came up to them, stopped and pulled down the window. The homeless came expectantly to the car for money, but the man said, "do you want me to get you a job? I know where you can get one." the homeless' face darkened as they stated, "no, I'm ok." Why did they say that? They were obviously not "ok." The man had tried to teach him to "fish," but the fact of the matter was, he didn't WANT to learn.
As my post is probably much too long now, I will simply say this: the world is deteriorating. Will you be the fridge to slow it down? The salt to preserve what's left? Or will you just live like you're "supposed to," and be "happy"? What do you choose?
One, I think I'm the only one who read through the entire thing! Two, to answer your question I try to be the fridge and the salt to save what we have left of the world. Living like the world wants you to only causes more damage. Unless the part of the world you're listening to is the part that tells you to be the salt and the fridge. Three, I heard another story about this group of people who came across a man on the street with a sign that said he needed money for food. So one of them said to him, "you want to come with us? we're going to get pizza you can have some if you like." and just like the guy in your story, he said no. I know it's not the exact same thing but it shows that if he was too lazy to come with them to get pizza, he's too lazy to learn to provide for himself. Some of the people in this world just baffle me!
DeleteYeah! some people just aren't willing...
DeleteAlec,
ReplyDeleteI don't know where to start right now, so I'll just get this part out of the way first. You have an amazing vocabulary, but I'm not gunna lie. I am very jealous of you, vocabulary is not my strong suit. I had to use the dictionary to read this post, and I was still confused on some parts. Now onto my response...
Like you, I had given my toys up when I was younger, but mine was for a different reason. The toys that I liked were "boy" toys and that I shouldn't play with them, so I gave them up because I didn't like being called weird. I also was a little more mature for my age, even though it may be hard to believe, but I was always able to talk to adults at a mature level of conversation.
And relating to the the quote about the fish, it is cute and idealistic. I can see how it relates to real life. You can do a guys work for him; it will help him for a bit, but if it is taught to him, he can go a lot farther with it.
Well, I honestly can't respond much more because I didn't quite understand much of this. You are to smart for my comprehension.
Oh Abby, I thought the same thing at first. I had to read this post about four times before I could even put my brain back into gear.
DeleteI think the easiest thing to do is take it in parts. Silly me, though, went for the whole post at once, and got stuck somewhere in between the first and last line. :/
alec, I have to say that I am severely jealous of your writing and vocabulary. You never stop amazing me. YOu are so quiet in class, but your writing says so much,
ReplyDeletei think you have the most colorful vocabulary in the school. I that there is one god and he created the heavens and the earth and he created us not some BANG. i disagree with you on the whole gun thing. Guns do not kill people people kill people. it has always been that way. There are creative ways to kill people guns are not the only way it is just the fastest. guns are a dangerous thing ill agree with you on that but you have to respect them. also almost all killings are linked to alcohol which means people
ReplyDeleteThat's not what I meant, Dominic, on the topic of guns. I understand the premise around which this declaration is based, and I never said that guns didn't serve a significant purpose. My comment on gun control was simply that guns should be... well, controlled--and restricted to those responsible, which obviously isn't my decision. I'm simply saying that I don't feel the U.S. enforces these restrictions as strictly as they should. I also understand that this is easier said than done.
DeleteI'm also not saying that I believe in the Big Bang Theory, but I know that many of the people that refute it are also unwilling to even learn about it. There's more to the theory than just... "bang." When described as such, it really does sound stupid. I try to keep an open mind as much as I can.
Taking on my own stance with the creation of everything, I believe that everything is random fate -- that is, one random happening leads to another, and another, and another, and so on until this exact point and time. The theory that it was just a "bang" is one we will never be able to prove, and the theory that god created everything follows suit. So, if we're going to get technical, you are both right and wrong in your statement.
DeleteAs for the gun thing, I completely agree with both you and Alec. People can't control themselves anywhere; saying this, the creation of the gun was a futile one, as no one knows how to use them responsibly. The United States cares more about new issues and less about the old ones, and this is why I predict our downfall over the next two to three hundred years.
Perhaps even sooner...
DeleteI'm a practicing Catholic and believe in both evolusion and creation. I believe that God set of the "big bang " that powered evolution to occur. He then created man and woman that evolved on their own. I believe in having faith and that what I do in this life will determine my outcome in the next. I don't needproof of God .. that's why it's called FAITH.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree, Maria.
DeleteI love the fat that you practically just said that you live your life via faith. faith is truely a powerful thing, it could move mountains. Its a great thing to live by.
DeleteThat was really insightful! I don't completely agree with your political views, but that's a story for another day.
ReplyDeleteWhat I do believe with a burning passion is the quote about fishing that I'm too lazy to type out all the way. But I'm sure you all know what I'm talking about. I think that teaching someone something is ultimately the best way to help someone out. When my sister asks me for help on her homework I go over the lesson with her and show her ways I used to remember things she has trouble with. Then she doesn't need to ask for my help any more. So it saves her from freaking out over the test in however long and it saves me some extra time, which is nice. And she knows that if she needs help with something else she can count on me to really help her and not do the work for her so she's not stuck on the tests. That quote is something I live my life by and I do everything I can to help through teaching.
Honestly i'm not even sure how in the world to reply to this so I will proceed to agree with you on the fact that Religion should not mixed in or even related to politics because in the first place politics are already messed up enough and if you add something people are so strong willed about like diffrent gods it would be like world war III practically over night.
ReplyDeleteYeah, I agree religion is a touchy subject!
DeleteI feel as though everyone has their idealistic dream on how our government and world should be run. I, for one am a firm believer in creation, but am also confused. I can't even begin to explain either but I've been brought up with Christian values.
ReplyDeleteI don't think anyone should be judged based on religion. If you don't believe in the same thing I do I'm not going to try and kill you for it. I think it all comes down to people being ridiculous.
DeleteThis was a VERY powerful post! I did not seed this coming at all! You arranged your ideas perfectly and I agree with you. I have never understood why the world must be ruled under one "ultimate" religion. I don't see why everyone can't just believe what they want. Then you have to remember that people are simpleminded fools. It's obvious that man will never see eye to eye so long as we are different. That will be the end of the human race. Ignorance
ReplyDelete